dc universe animated original movies, part 3: the dcamu era, part 2

batman: the killing joke (comic 1988)

writer: alan moore

artist: brian bolland

batman: the killing joke (movie 2016)

“hello. i came to talk. i’ve been thinking lately. about you and me. about what’s going to happen to us, in the end. we’re going to kill each other, aren’t we? perhaps you’ll kill me. perhaps i’ll kill you. perhaps sooner. perhaps later. i just wanted to know that i’d made a genuine attempt to talk things over and avert that outcome. just once.”

was it morally reprehensible?

yes.

but was it a bad movie?

… also yes.

so, obviously i have my problems with the graphic novel. and obviously a lot of those problems are going to be baked into any adaptation of it. i’ll grant you that. i mean, those seem like great reasons to not adapt that particular comic, but i suppose that’s asking for too much.

but to recognize that one of the biggest complaints about the source material is that it treats barbara like a prop rather than a character, and to say “don’t worry, we got this” and add an extended prologue where batman and batgirl are fucking and think you fixed it is … yeah. that’s… a thing you can do, i guess?

you guys understand that the reason we have a problem with fridging is that it sacrifices female characters for the sake of male characters’ angst, right? and giving batman an additional reason to be upset about the attack on barbara … is not an improvement in that regard … right…?

right…??? guys…???? c-rank

🌑🌒🌓🌔🌕🌖🌗🌘🌑

justice league dark (film 2017)

more like justice league DORK amirite?

dc universe animated original movies, part 2 the dcamu era, part 1

the second era of the dc universe original movies was introduced by flashpoint paradox, an adaptation of the flashpoint arc. this led to a continuity known as the dc animated movie universe, which was basically a series of fairly faithful adaptations of the new 52 line of comics.

i actually like most of these, but it was admittedly a little disappointing to see these direct-to-video animated features go from kind of all over the board to frequently being very predictable.

there were a few movies that didn’t follow the dcamu continuity here and there, but the bulk of the team’s resources was clearly devoted to this new continuity.

it’s not difficult to understand why. from a business standpoint, it’s probably easier to get people to come back over and over when they more or less know what they’re getting, and also harder for them to skip individual entries that might not otherwise capture their interest if it’s all part of an interconnected series. i mean, that’s basically the mcu’s entire business model, right? that’s just how franchises work these days. this is just that on a much smaller scale.

what was pretty frustrating for me as a fan, and probably a big part of why i got disenchanted back when i was watching these as they came out, is that this was also when they decided that almost every movie needed to be either a batman or justice league movie. there was even a non-batman movie that had “batman” cynically slapped on the title just because he appeared in that movie for like… probably a grand total of five minutes if you add all his scenes up.

still, this series got so dang reliably good at this point, pretty much every new entry is a must-watch when it comes out. i don’t think many other direct-to-video series can truthfully claim that.

also due to the sheer number of entries in this era of the series, i’ve decided to divide my reviews of it into two parts.

🌑🌒🌓🌔🌕🌖🌗🌘🌑

flashpoint (comic 2011)

writer: geoff johns

artists: andy kubert & sandra hope & jesse delperdang

justice league: the flashpoint paradox (movie 2013)

“there’s only one thing i know about life. i know some things happen by chance, and some things happen because we make them happen.”

you probably got used to hearing me say this in my review of the first batch of dc universe original movies, so it’s only fitting that i start my first review by offering for context that i saw the movie long before i read the comic it’s based on. i’m pretty impressed, as i often am by these, by how closely this actually follows the comic it’s based on.

the story in both versions goes to some pretty grimdark places i’m not wild about but am a lot more forgiving about given that it’s an alternate future a la x-men’s days of future past. and the action was pretty great and it was a very satisfyingly pulpy storyline.

the movie followed the basic storyline of the comic, but it streamlined a few things, eliminated some minor characters, and expanded on the core scenes it kept. in the end i think the movie is, for the most part, actually noticeably better than the comic.